Insurance basics
How to protect yourself from insurance fraud in Canada
Insurance fraud prevention tips every Canadian homeowner and driver should know.
When it comes to protecting yourself from fraud, the best defense isn't fear. It's knowledge.
Insurance fraud affects all of us. It costs Canadians billions of dollars every year, and those costs don’t stay with insurance companies. They get passed along in the form of higher premiums for everyone. Fraud is also a safety issue: staged car accidents and unvetted contractors put real people at real risk.
Here’s the thing: staying safe doesn’t require expertise. Those behind these schemes count on confusion and pressure to catch people off guard. Learn about their most common tactics, and you’re already in a much stronger position.
This article covers the most common schemes targeting Canadian homeowners and drivers, and exactly what to do if you encounter one.
Key Takeaways
Home insurance fraud: how to spot contractor scams and title fraud
Auto insurance fraud: identifying staged accidents and tow truck schemes
Universal red flags: four warning signs to always watch for
What to do if you think you’re being targeted
Home Insurance Fraud Prevention: Common Scams and How to Avoid Them
Your home is likely your biggest asset, which makes it a prime target. Home-related insurance fraud often strikes at the most vulnerable moments: right after a storm, during a renovation, or when you’re navigating a stressful life change. Understanding what your home insurance covers is one of the best ways to spot when something doesn’t add up.
The more you know about how these schemes operate, the harder you are to target.
The “Door-Knocker” Contractor Scam
Someone shows up at your door, often right after a storm, offering a “free” roof inspection or claiming they have “leftover materials” from a job down the street and can give you a great deal. They’re friendly, they seem knowledgeable, and they’re in a hurry.
This is a classic setup. The “inspection” often results in manufactured or exaggerated damage, leading to a fraudulent insurance claim, sometimes filed without your knowledge. You can end up with substandard repairs, a voided warranty, and a claim on your insurance history that affects your future premiums.
What to do instead:
Always verify that contractors are licensed, bonded, and insured before any work begins
Get multiple quotes for any significant repair
Never let someone file an insurance claim on your behalf without your full understanding and agreement
Keep a digital paper trail: photos before and after work, plus all receipts and contracts
Identity Theft and Policy Takeover
Someone posing as you contacts your insurer to change policy details, redirect claims payments, or add coverage under your name. This type of fraud can go undetected for a long time. Often you won’t notice until you try to file a claim and find something has changed.
What to do instead:
Review your policy annually. Confirm that all details, coverage levels, and contact information are accurate
Set up online account access so you can monitor your policy at any time
Contact your insurer immediately if you receive unexpected correspondence about your policy
Mortgage and Title Fraud
In title fraud, criminals use stolen personal information to forge documents and transfer ownership of your home, then take out a mortgage against it. It sounds extreme, but it happens.
What to do instead:
Protect your personal information carefully, especially your SIN and government-issued ID
Consider title insurance, which can help protect your legal ownership of your home
Monitor your credit report regularly for any unfamiliar activity
Staying Safe on the Road: Auto Insurance Fraud
Auto insurance fraud often happens fast. It tends to strike in the chaotic moments right after a collision, when you’re stressed, disoriented, and just trying to figure out what happened. Knowing what your auto insurance covers and how claims work puts you in a much stronger position at the scene.
Here’s what to watch for.
The Staged Accident
Also known as a “swoop and squat,” this is when a driver intentionally cuts in front of you and brakes suddenly, causing you to rear-end them. Because rear-end collisions typically assign fault to the driver behind, this positions them to file a claim, often with multiple fake “injured passengers” who weren’t even in the vehicle.
What to do:
Take photos of the scene, all vehicles, visible damage, and the other driver’s license and plates
Note how many people were in the other vehicle at the time of the accident
Call the police. An official report creates an unbiased account of the incident
If anything feels off, tell your insurer. Let them investigate
Tow Truck “Chasers”
A tow truck appears at the scene, fast and seemingly out of nowhere, and pressures you to go to “their” repair shop. The driver may be aggressive or insist that your insurer has already approved it. They haven’t.
These “chaser” operations are often connected to repair shops that inflate bills, perform unnecessary work, or file fraudulent claims, sometimes without the vehicle owner’s knowledge.
What to do:
You have the right to choose your own tow truck and repair shop
Stick to insurer-approved or reputable facilities you’ve researched yourself
Don’t sign anything at the scene under pressure
The Fraudsters Playbook: 4 Universal Red Flags
Whether it’s a home repair scam or an auto scheme, fraudsters tend to use the same pressure tactics. Keep these four red flags in mind. They apply across the board.
High-pressure urgency: “You must sign this now or the deal is gone.” Legitimate professionals don’t rush you into decisions. Pressure is a tactic, not a reason.
Cash-only requests: Avoiding a paper trail is a classic sign of a scam. Always use traceable payment methods and get receipts.
Deals that seem too good: Rates dramatically lower than any competitor, “free” repairs that bypass your deductible, or offers that appear out of nowhere. If it seems too good, trust that instinct.
Unsolicited contact: Random texts, calls, or door knocks asking for sensitive policy details or banking information. Your insurer will never cold-call you for this kind of information.
What to Do If You Suspect Fraud
If something feels off, whether it’s a contractor at your door, a suspicious accident, or an unexpected call about your policy, trust your gut and take these steps:
Don’t engage. Walk away, hang up, or close the door. You’re not obligated to respond under pressure. Your personal safety always comes first.
Notify your insurer. Even if no claim has been filed yet, alerting your provider early protects your account and helps prevent fraud from escalating. To learn more about how to make a claim, visit our Claims page.
Report it. Contact the Insurance Bureau of Canada (IBC) via their anonymous, toll-free TIPS Line at 1-877-IBC-TIPS (1-877-422-8477) or submit a tip online at ibc.ca. Reporting helps protect other Canadians too. If you have questions about your policy in the meantime, our FAQs are a good place to start.
Knowledge Is Your Best Policy
Fraud prevention isn’t about being paranoid. It’s about being prepared. The more familiar you are with common schemes, the harder you are to target.
Staying informed is the most effective thing you can do. Fraud relies on catching people off guard. You’ve just made that a lot more difficult.
If you have questions about your current coverage or if you encounter something that doesn’t feel right, our Licensed Insurance Advisors are ready to help. Call PC® Insurance at 1-877-253-8177.
New to PC® Insurance? Get a personalized quote in minutes.
